The town didn’t have a superhero, but we had Mrs. Virginia Jenkins, and honestly, that was better. She was an elderly woman who never had any kids of her own, but she sure loved the ones who lived in the neighborhood. Her husband had passed long before I was born, so she lived alone. Her house was in the middle of town, next door to mine, and filled with plants. She fed the stray cats that lived in the area, and any child that happened upon her door left with a full belly and a plate of cookies to take home to their parents.
Her kindness made people love her, but it was those cookies that made the magic happen.
Yes, they were truly magical.
I once heard my mom say, “Those cookies can make anything better” and it was true.
Living next door to Mrs. Jenkins meant that saw more than the other kids in my class. My bedroom window looked out onto her house. People would come to her house in tears, and after having a few of her cookies and some tea with her out in her garden, they left with a smile on their face. Every. Single. Time. Without fail, Mrs. Jenkins made their problems vanish into thin air.
I was only twelve so it wasn’t like I had any real problems, except the time Bethany Brooks decided she no longer liked me and tried to turn all my other friends against me. That was the first time I knocked on Mrs. Jenkins’ door with tears in my eyes.
“Oh dear Jessica, what is the matter? Come inside, I have a fresh batch of cookies coming out of the oven, tell me all about it.”
She sat me down with a glass of milk and the softest, warmest, sweetest chocolate chip cookies I’d ever tasted in my life.
“My best friend hates me,” I told her, tears running down my face. “And I don’t know why.”
“Oh sweetie, kids can be so cruel,” she said. “I’m sorry.”
“And now Michelle and Katie are sitting with her at lunch and ignoring me too.”
“Here, take some cookies with you to school tomorrow,” she said, packing up about eight large cookies for me. “Share them with your friends and try talking to them, ask them if there’s anything you can do to repair your friendship.”
I listened to her and did just that.
Bethany initially laughed at me, but as soon as I pulled out the cookies, both Michelle and Katie’s eyes were wide. “Are those Mrs. Jenkins’ cookies?”
“They are, would you like some?”
Bethany was no longer laughing. Michelle and Katie nodded eagerly but looked over at their friend, as if seeking approval first. Bethany sighed, and after a few seconds said, “You can join us if you’d like.” She grabbed the largest cookie for herself.
Mrs. Jenkins’ cookies had worked! My mom had been right, they made everything better. I now understood the power of her cookies, and knew exactly why anyone who showed up at her doorstep could have their problems solved in an instant. Magic did exist, and it was baked right into the dough.
No one believed me, even with all the proof I had collected over the months. My rat Rudy and I would sit at my window every day after school and watch Mrs. Jenkins’ house. Some days, no one came by and it was a slow night. But most days, she’d get a visitor and I’d have a story to tell.
“That’s Mr. Grisham, he was diagnosed with cancer last year, and he visits frequently. He always leaves smiling, and mom says the chemo seems to have shrunk his cancer enough that he’s in remission. But we know it wasn’t the chemo, Rudy, it was the cookies… I just need to document my findings to prove it.” I started doing just that. I pulled out a composition notebook that I used to document everyone who came and went from Mrs. Jenkins’ place. Rudy was my witness.
I didn’t have much time for anything else, since I had very serious research to conduct and couldn’t miss someone coming or going. It started to impact my friendships at school, but I didn’t care. I had Rudy after all.
One day at school, Bethany asked me,“What are you doing this weekend, Jess?”
“Oh, I’m, err, umm doing some scientific research.
“Mr. Foster didn’t assign us any science homework this weekend.”
“I know, it’s my own research,” I said.
She scrunched up her face. My friends at school would never understand, but it was fine, Rudy understood the importance of my work, so instead of going to the pool with Bethany that weekend, I stayed at home with my rat and documented the people who came and went from the house next door.
Imagine my surprise when Bethany herself showed up at Mrs. Jenkins’ door with tears in her eyes.
“Hmph, and she always laughed when I told her that Mrs. Jenkins’ was magical,” I muttered to Rudy as I cuddled him close to my chest. “I guess she’s here to see for herself.”
I leaned in close to try and see into the window, and could barely make out their movements between the curtains. No doubt she was getting some cookies and milk, just like I did when I went for help. Bethany left the house about thirty minutes later with a pack of cookies tucked under her arm and a smile on her face.
“Even more proof, Rudy. Maybe she will finally believe me–”
The sound of the doorbell ringing had interrupted my thoughts. It couldn’t be, I thought to myself, looking back out the window. I hadn’t watched which direction Bethany had went when she left the house.
My mom’s voice called from behind the door, “Jess, you have company.”
She opened the door and there stood Bethany with her offering of cookies held out before her. Mom left the room and I just stared at my sometimes best friend, sometimes arch nemesis.
“What is this about? Weren’t you going to the pool with Katie and Michelle?”
“They canceled on me. They always do if you don’t come along,” she said. “But I don’t care. I miss you, Jess. I miss how we used to spend so much time together but it feels like something has changed.”
Something had changed. In both of us.
Bethany continued. “I know I’ve been mean to you recently, but it’s because I’m jealous.”
“Jealous?”
“Yes, I know that Michelle and Katie like you more than me, and now you’ve been spending less and less time with me so clearly you don’t want to be my friend anymore–”
I held up a hand to stop Bethany. “Wait, hold up… you saw Mrs. Jenkins because you wanted help with our friendship?”
Bethany nodded and held out the cookies. “She said to give you some cookies and to tell you how I felt, and that hopefully it would repair our friendship.”
Looking down at the cookies, I could never say no to one… but did I really want to have Mrs. Jenkins’ magic used on me? Then again, there was nothing to fix with our friendship. I wasn’t upset with her, I’d just been more interested in my research and didn’t realize my friends had missed me.
What harm could come from taking a cookie if there’s nothing that needs to be fixed, I thought.
“I’m sorry, Bethany. I didn’t realize you felt left out. I’ve just been busy with my own stuff.” I held the cookie to my lips, hesitant. Would it change me somehow? Would I feel the magic coursing through my body? The warmth of the freshly baked cookie was impossible to resist though, and I finally took a bite, savoring the sweetness for a moment before taking stock of how I felt.
I felt a tingle inside of my body starting at my toes. Just a little bit of a tingle, I had to really focus on it to feel it at all, but I convinced myself that I felt something. Even though I didn’t need the magic to help me remain friends with Bethany, it was still there. It comforted me knowing that I was right all along.
“Really? We can still be best friends, Jess?”
“Yes, of course,” I said. “As long as you don’t mind sharing with Rudy, that is. We’ve been spending a lot of time together.”
She laughed and wiped away the tears. “What a relief. I thought I would be the one sitting alone at the lunch table.” We sat down on the floor and ate a few more cookies as Ruby slept on my lap. He was sleeping more and more lately, I thought to myself. Normally he would be interested in stealing the cookies from us, he loved snacks. But I was keeping him awake and playing with him more than usual, that had to be it. I stroked his white fur as he slept.
As the days went by, I tried to spend less time on my research and more time with my friends, even as I was yearning to learn more about Mrs. Jenkins’ magic. I didn’t want my friends to be sad.
After a sleepover at Bethany’s house one weekend, I rushed home and was about to run up the stairs when my mom stopped me. The look on her face told me that something was wrong.
“What is it?” I asked.
Dad joined her and they shared a look. I didn’t like that look. Tears filled mom’s eyes. “Honey, we need to tell you something–”
“What is it? You’re not getting a divorce are you?”
“What? No, where did you–” They looked at each other again.
“Michelle’s parents are getting divorced.”
Dad lowered himself so he was at my level and took my hands in his. “Your mom and I aren’t getting a divorce, I promise you that.”
“Then what is it?” My heart pounded in my chest. Something was wrong. Something was very wrong.
Mom’s voice cracked. “It’s Rudy, he–”
“He what?”
Mom couldn’t finish, dad had to take over. “He’s gone, sweetie.”
“Gone? What do you mean? Did he get out of the cage?” I pulled my hands free from dad’s and ran up the stairs to my room.
My parents were right behind me as I entered my bedroom. Rudy’s cage was missing from the corner. It was just empty space.
“Where is he?” Tears welled in my eyes. In my heart, I already knew. Rats didn’t live that long, my parents warned me when we got him the year before. He’d grown tired as of lately, but I chocked that up to spending more time with him.
“He’s gone, Jess,” dad said. “Your mom came up here to feed him this morning and he was…gone.”
Gone.
Just like that.
My best friend. My real best friend. I had spent so much time with Bethany, the girl who had made me sit alone at lunch, that I wasn’t even there for my real best friend.
Mom held out her arms to hug me, and I thought about falling into those arms as the tears filled my eyes.
“No, it can’t be. I have to fix this.” With fists balled up at my sides, I ran back down the stairs and out the front door. There was a downpour, but I didn’t care. My parents were behind me, calling out for me as I pushed open the gate to Mrs. Jenkins’ property.
She can bring him back. She can fix this. Her cookies can make anything better, that’s what mom said. I believed it completely.
I knocked on the door and it opened almost immediately.
“Jessica, are you okay? Come inside, you’re soaked to the bone, dear.” I noticed she waved at my parents before closing the door. Good, I didn’t want them here. They didn’t believe in her magic, not fully at least.
“Rudy…. Rudy….” I sobbed, feeling as my chest had been crushed. Talking was hard when I felt like I couldn’t even breathe.
“Who is Rudy, dear?”
“My pet rat. He’s… He’s…. Gone.”
“Oh, honey, I’m so sorry to hear that. Let’s dry you off, and we can sit in front of the fire and have some cookies, and you can tell me all about him.”
She grabbed a towel and gently helped to dry my hair and face, wiping away the tears.
“I need you to fix it.” I sobbed. “I need you to make it better.”
“Fix what, sweetheart?”
“Rudy. I need you to bring him back. With your cookies.” I choked out the words.
“Oh, Jessica…”
“What? I know you can do it. I see the magic your cookies have on others. You made my friends forgive me, and you even helped repair my friendship with Bethany. And Mr. Grisham’s cancer–”
“Oh sweetie, I can’t bring Rudy back.” Her voice was low and solemn. “I would if I could. Trust me, I would love it if I had that kind of power–”
“But you do! With your cookies!”
Oh honey, my cookies are just that – cookies. There’s nothing magical about them.”
“Then how come you have people coming to your door sad or upset, and they leave with a smile on your face? How do you solve all of their problems?”
“Jess, dear, I don’t solve their problems,” she said softly, kneeling down to look me in the eyes. “Some problems, like with your Rudy, can’t be easily solved. But sometimes just talking about it with a friend over some delicious treats can momentarily make things easier to deal with.”
“But I want Rudy back.”
“Tell me all about him. He might be gone, but he will always live on through your memories and the stories you tell.”
She took my hand and led me into the living room. A fire was going.
“I’ll be right back,” she said as she slipped into the kitchen. She returned with a tray of cookies and two big glasses of milk. She sat them down on the table in front of us. “Go on.”
I took a cookie, but I looked at it closely. Was she telling the truth, were they really just cookies? I swore I had felt something when Bethany had given me one. Had I imagined it?
I took a bite. Part of me was expecting for Rudy to appear in front of me, and when he didn’t, the tears started to fall once more.
Mrs. Jenkins put her arm over my shoulder and hugged me close. “There, there,” she said. “I know it’s hard. It’s clear you loved him very, very much. He was lucky to have you.”
I took another bite.
And another.
“You can tell me all about him when you’re ready, Jessica. I’d love to hear all about him.”
I thought about Rudy and all the good times we had. He loved trying to steal food from me, and the way his whiskers twitched when he was getting chin scratches always made me smile. I started telling Mrs. Jenkins all about him.
And at some point after the second or third cookie, the tears stopped falling. “You’re know something, Mrs. Jenkins’, you’re wrong.”
“About what?” She cocked her head to the side with a confused expression.
“You and your cookies are magical. I’m starting to feel a little better already.”